Israel Medical Association Journal

Almost three-quarters of a century ago an American surgeon named Frederick Edward Mohs, had the idea of excising skin cancers and examining the margins before the closure of the surgical wound. In this manner he thought the patient would get better treatment with the best cosmetic result.

Mohs micrographic surgery (MMS) in its present format has been used as a surgical method for treating skin cancers for the last 70 years. The method became popular with American dermatologists 54 years ago when the original Mohs technique was modified into its fresh tissue modality [2] and in the rest of the Western world and Israel more than 35 years ago. Variations of MMS started to appear and indications for surgery also expanded. At the beginning, MMS was indicated mainly for basal and squamous cell carcinomas–nonmelanoma skin cancers (NMSC). Knowledge has been collected and today the method is applicable for a variety of other skin cancers such as melanoma in situ, microcystic adnexal carcinoma, dermatofibrosarcoma protuberans (DFSP), and other adnexal and spindle cell tumors. In this issue of the Israel Medical Association Journal (IMAJ), Landov and colleagues [3] showed the value of MMS for the treatment of DFSP.

Background: According to Hamas sources, many Israeli hostages in Gaza were killed by indiscriminate Israeli airstrikes, together with a large number of Palestinian citizens.

Objectives: To verify whether the estimated death rate of Israeli hostages was similar to the estimated death rate of Gaza citizens from these acts of war.

Methods: We used two estimates of hostage death rates, one obtained from Israeli intelligence sources, and one published by a Hamas spokesperson. We used the Palestinian casualty rates published by the Palestinian Ministry of Health. We compared death rates using Fisher's exact test.

Results: By 30 December 2023, the rate of Israeli hostage death was 23/238 (9.7%) according to Israeli intelligence sources, and 60/238 (25.2%) according to Hamas. Both figures are strikingly and significantly higher than the death rate among Palestinians, estimated to be 19,667/2.2 million (0.89%) by 19 December 2023 (P < 0.0001).

Conclusions: Israeli airstrikes as the cause of death of Israeli hostages are implausible unless they were specifically exposed to these strikes more than Palestinian citizens.